Kaikki raportit
Russian Railroads raportit
#13684: "Track Scoring is not scoring correctly"
Mitä tämä raportti koskee?
Mitä tapahtui? Valitse alta
Säännöt: pelin sääntöä ei ole noudatettu
Tarkka kuvaus
• Mitä osaa säännöistä BGA:n sovellus ei noudattanut
Track Scoring• Onko sääntörikkomus nähtävillä pelin toistossa? Jos kyllä, mikä on siirron numero?
Move 78, you can add up the total of the tracks and it does not equal the total that is showing on the player card.
• Mikä on selaimesi?
Google Chrome v77
Raportin historia
10. loka 2019 20:51 • bobbo489 • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
Trans Siberian has Grey at 5, Brown at 4, Natural at 3, White at 2. Total should be 5*1 + 4*2 + 3*4 + 2*7 = 39
St Pete has Grey at 8, Brown at 2, 2x the row is in effect = (8*1 + 2*2) * 2 = 24
Total should be 63, total showing on name is 57
St Pete has Grey at 8, Brown at 2, 2x the row is in effect = (8*1 + 2*2) * 2 = 24
Total should be 63, total showing on name is 57
21. marras 2019 20:53 • Wigbolt • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
I made the same mistake which brought me to your post and others (where it became clear to me I was calculating my score wrongly).
You should only count the number of tracks _until_ the next colour track. Not all the way back to the beginning of the railroad. The different colour tracks don't overlap.
So, TransSib: Grey 5, Brown 4, Natural 3, White 2 comes down to:
1 grey, 1 brown, 1 nat and 2 white tracks = 1 + 2 + 3 + 2*4 = 14
Likewise, St.P in your example has 6 (not 8) grey and 2 brown = (6*1 + 2*2) * 2 = 20
Now the totals don't add up to 57, and I can't see the game situation anymore, but I'm sure we're missing something else (doublers, industry, Kiev?). Anyway this is what I could see from your example. Hope this helps.
You should only count the number of tracks _until_ the next colour track. Not all the way back to the beginning of the railroad. The different colour tracks don't overlap.
So, TransSib: Grey 5, Brown 4, Natural 3, White 2 comes down to:
1 grey, 1 brown, 1 nat and 2 white tracks = 1 + 2 + 3 + 2*4 = 14
Likewise, St.P in your example has 6 (not 8) grey and 2 brown = (6*1 + 2*2) * 2 = 20
Now the totals don't add up to 57, and I can't see the game situation anymore, but I'm sure we're missing something else (doublers, industry, Kiev?). Anyway this is what I could see from your example. Hope this helps.
28. maalis 2020 23:09 • djles • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
I Had the same problem with trans Siberian. Ik think the problem is that the revaluation doesn't count correctly.
10. elo 2020 12:55 • Tikhonov • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
It's not bug (see Wigbolt's comment). Additionally, you have to consider which tracks your locomotives actually reach.
4. joulu 2020 21:49 • Tanja294 • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
St Petersburg shows 42 points.
But I do have the doubler for brown 3 points and beige 6 points and white 10 points (in the german rules it says that this count for the tableaut and not only for transsiberian!).
And I reached with the grey the field eight. And the loc activates field 7. So double (x2) points of the track.
So Grey at 8, Brown at 4, beige at 2
I thought it is then (only counted the colourful fields - not until the beginning - I added the steps to see it :-) )
beige (6+6) x 2 = 24
brown (3+3) x 2 = 12
grey (1+1+1+1) x 2 = 8
made in sum 44.
It is not about the 2 points - it is about the logic, because you plan with the rules your scores, aren't you?
Perhaps as additional hint you could make a possibility to see the detail points of each track? Helps a lot of players, I think.
Thank you for all your work :-)
But I do have the doubler for brown 3 points and beige 6 points and white 10 points (in the german rules it says that this count for the tableaut and not only for transsiberian!).
And I reached with the grey the field eight. And the loc activates field 7. So double (x2) points of the track.
So Grey at 8, Brown at 4, beige at 2
I thought it is then (only counted the colourful fields - not until the beginning - I added the steps to see it :-) )
beige (6+6) x 2 = 24
brown (3+3) x 2 = 12
grey (1+1+1+1) x 2 = 8
made in sum 44.
It is not about the 2 points - it is about the logic, because you plan with the rules your scores, aren't you?
Perhaps as additional hint you could make a possibility to see the detail points of each track? Helps a lot of players, I think.
Thank you for all your work :-)
30. heinä 2022 5:56 • SmilinTweety • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
I came here for the same reason - for this game: boardgamearena.com/3/russianrailroads?table=286458190#
I now see though that the tracks don't overlap and so the scoring was done according the scoring section of the rules here: www.ultraboardgames.com/russian-railroads/game-rules.php "Scoring the 3 railroads" . I just hadn't looked at the scores that closely before.
I now see though that the tracks don't overlap and so the scoring was done according the scoring section of the rules here: www.ultraboardgames.com/russian-railroads/game-rules.php "Scoring the 3 railroads" . I just hadn't looked at the scores that closely before.
13. maalis 2023 18:17 • Talon378 • Ohjelmoijat eivät ole vielä löytäneet bugia:
Table #356257552
I ran into this issue as well. I feel like the issue is specific to the Trans Siberian Rail track at the top.
I ran into this issue as well. I feel like the issue is specific to the Trans Siberian Rail track at the top.
Lisää jotain tähän raporttiin
Lisää tähän mitä tahansa, minkä katsot oleelliseksi tämän bugin toisintamiseksi tai ehdotuksesi ymmärtämiseksi:
- Toinen pöydän tunnus / siirron numero
- Ratkaisiko F5 ongelman?
- Ilmestyykö ongelma useita kertoja? Joka kerta? Satunnaisesti?
- Jos sinulla on kuvankaappaus tästä bugista, voit käyttää Imgur.com:a sen lähettämiseksi. Kopioi ja liitä linkki tähän.
