#8376: "Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make too many VPs/coins."
Mitä tämä raportti koskee?
Mitä tapahtui? Valitse alta
Mitä tapahtui? Valitse alta
Ennen ilmoituksen tekoa, tarkista onko sellainen jo olemassa samasta aiheesta
Jos kyllä, ole ystävällinen ja ÄÄNESTÄ tätä raporttia. Eniten ääniä saaneet raportit laitetaan ETUSIJALLE!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Tarkka kuvaus
-
• Kopioi/liitä virheilmoitus näytöltäsi, jos sait sellaisen.
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." -
• Selitä mitä halusit tehdä, mitä teit ja mitä tapahtui
move378
• Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Ole hyvä ja kopioi teksti englanniksi oman kielesi sijasta. Jos sinulla on kuvakaappaus tästä bugista (hyvä käytäntö), voit käyttää valitsemaasi kuvien isännöintipalvelua (snipboard.io ladataksesi sen ja kopioidaksesi/liittääksesi linkin tähän. Onko tämä teksti saatavilla käännösjärjestelmässä? Jos on, onko sen käännöksestä yli 24 tuntia?
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Selitä ehdotuksesti tarkasti ja ytimekkäästi, jotta se on ymmärrettävissä niin helposti kuin mahdollista.
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Mitä näytöllä näkyi kun olit estettynä (Tyhjä ruutu? Osa pelin käyttöliittymästä? Virheilmoitus?)
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Mitä osaa säännöistä BGA:n sovellus ei noudattanut
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." -
• Onko sääntörikkomus nähtävillä pelin toistossa? Jos kyllä, mikä on siirron numero?
move378
• Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Minkä pelin toiminnon halusit suorittaa?
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." -
• Mitä yritit tehdä tämän pelitoiminnon käynnistymiseksi?
move378
-
• Mitä tapahtui kun yritit tehdä tämän (virheilmoitus, pelin tilapalkin viesti, ...)?
• Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Missä vaiheessa peliä ongelma ilmeni (mikä oli silloinen pelin ohje)?
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." -
• Mitä tapahtui kun yritit tehdä tämän pelin toiminnon (virheilmoitus, pelin tilapalkin viesti, ...)?
move378
• Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Kuvaile näyttöongelmaa. Jos sinulla on kuvakaappaus tästä bugista (hyvä käytäntö), voit käyttää valitsemaasi kuvien isännöintipalvelua (snipboard.io ladataksesi sen ja kopioidaksesi/liittääksesi linkin tähän.
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Ole hyvä ja kopioi teksti englanniksi oman kielesi sijasta. Jos sinulla on kuvakaappaus tästä bugista (hyvä käytäntö), voit käyttää valitsemaasi kuvien isännöintipalvelua (snipboard.io ladataksesi sen ja kopioidaksesi/liittääksesi linkin tähän. Onko tämä teksti saatavilla käännösjärjestelmässä? Jos on, onko sen käännöksestä yli 24 tuntia?
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
-
• Selitä ehdotuksesti tarkasti ja ytimekkäästi, jotta se on ymmärrettävissä niin helposti kuin mahdollista.
1 year ago,this bag is said "notabag",but it's a BAG.
The rule,official PDF, says ”Each time,during the captain phase,the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on cargo ship,he earns one extra victory point."
All communities, I know,that is BGG,BSW and Jpapanese community.They use Small wharf and Harbor/Lighthouse make only 1 VP/coin rule.
Thank you for reading.
No one says "each time he loads _a different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP." • Mikä on selaimesi?
Mozilla v5
Raportin historia
Le petit quai permet de charger jusqu'à 5 marchandises différentes en une seule fois, et il me semble clair que le port doit procurer un VP par chargement, et non 1 VP par marchandise différente si chargée en une seule fois.
Reference rules:
www.ravensburger.com/content/wcm/mediadata/pdf/Microsites/Alea/Puerto%20Rico/US-SR%201.pdf
(this rule is more detailed that the one you provided a link to)
Lighthouse (captain phase): +1 doubloon for each _type of good_ loaded
In the Captain phase, each time a player with an occupied lighthouse loads
goods onto a ship he earns one extra doubloon. If he is also the Captain, he earns
1 additional doubloon on his first turn.
Harbor (Captain Phase): +1 VP for each _goods type_ loaded
In the Captain phase, if a player has an occupied harbor, each time he loads _a
different type of good_ onto a ship he earns one extra VP (see example under
Wharf, below)
Strange to see how that reference rule actually exactly says what you say is not written :)
NB: when talking about online communities, please include a link. Otherwise I can't check.
Under Harbor it says: "Each time, during the captain phase, the owner of an occupied harbor loads goods on a cargo ship, he earns one extra VP." The example following this does not mention good "types" at all, and while it includes an example with Wharf, it provides none with Small Wharf. This is the exact document you linked to, on pg. 10.
I searched the entire document for "harbor" and there are no references to what you quoted above. I searched the entire document for the phrase "goods type" (like your quote of Harbor says) and the only place that phrase is used is under the warehouses. I see no other references to Harbor that aren't just general comments. I also did a search for "lighthouse" and don't see the quoted paragraph anywhere either. (It says it's "similar" to Harbor but 1 doubloon rather than 1 VP, but mentions nothing of "types of goods.")
I don't know what was different about the file that was linked to, but it doesn't say what you claim.
I did link to one post at BGG (in the Puerto Rico thread I'm about to go post on), and it agrees with this. It's nothing "official," but I didn't find anything official on BGG.
I have to agree with original poster of this bug. (Though I don't call incorrect rules "bugs," but that's another story.)
At this date, the reference version is still available in Google cache so you can check it out:
webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:3GNdX7430TkJ:https://www.ravensburger.com/content/wcm/mediadata/pdf/Microsites/Alea/Puerto%2520Rico/US-SR%25201.pdf
And I consider it a reference version since it is a consolidated version of the rules with both expansions and the new art for the game, so it's more up to date that the rules linked by the creator of this bug report.
The equivalent latest rulebook in German is clear about lighthouse and harbor bringing 1 doubloon / point per shipment and not per type of goods shipped.
This has now been fixed.
Lisää jotain tähän raporttiin
- Toinen pöydän tunnus / siirron numero
- Ratkaisiko F5 ongelman?
- Ilmestyykö ongelma useita kertoja? Joka kerta? Satunnaisesti?
- Jos sinulla on kuvakaappaus tästä bugista (hyvä käytäntö), voit käyttää valitsemaasi kuvien isännöintipalvelua (snipboard.io ladataksesi sen ja kopioidaksesi/liittääksesi linkin tähän.
